ÐÓ°ÉÂÛ̳

 Skip to content   Skip to footer navigation 

Ice cream maker reviews

Buy smarter with ÐÓ°ÉÂÛ̳membership

Join CHOICE

Or Learn more

Last updated: 27 September 2023
Fact-checked

Fact-checked

Checked for accuracy by our qualified verifiers and subject experts. Find out more about fact-checking at CHOICE.

An ice cream maker allows you to create delicious ice cream and frozen desserts from the comfort of your own home. But are they worth it?

Our experts lab test models from Breville, Cuisinart, KitchenAid, Magimix and more, giving an assessment on:

  • how well each one makes an ice cream, sorbet and vegan frozen yoghurt
  • how easy each ice cream maker is to assemble and use, including using the controls and ease of cleaning.
 

We've also partnered with on this update to show the ratings the Ethical Consumer Group gives to each company.

Did you know ÐÓ°ÉÂÛ̳tests more than just ice cream makers? Check out our Top 50 product reviews.

Shopping links on the ÐÓ°ÉÂÛ̳website

ÐÓ°ÉÂÛ̳is an independent, nonprofit organisation dedicated to helping consumers. Clicking a link will take you to a retailer's website to shop. While we make money if you buy through some retailer links, this doesn't influence any of our rankings. 100% of the money we make goes straight back into our nonprofit mission. We're currently testing this service and will consider providing more shopping links in the future. .

Brand

Expand to view more details.

List of brands we tested in this review.

Price

Expand to view more details.

This is the manufacturer's recommended retail price.

Recommended products

Remove product

Member only

This test score is for members only. Join now to unlock our expert results.

Already a member?

Type

Expand to view more details.

There are two main types of ice cream maker – compressor (self-freezing) and freezer bowl (freeze-first). We've also tested a food processor that makes ice cream.

Performance score

Expand to view more details.

The performance score is made up of three tests – vanilla ice cream, lemon sorbet and vegan frozen yoghurt – all weighted equally.


Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Remove product

Member only

This test score is for members only. Join now to unlock our expert results.

Already a member?

Bowl capacity (L)

Warranty (years)

Expand to view more details.

The manufacturer's stated warranty.

Included in this review

Members-only access
  • ÐÓ°ÉÂÛ̳Expert Rating
  • Vegan frozen yoghurt score
  • Recommended
  • Lemon sorbet score
  • Vanilla ice cream score
  • Performance score
  • Ease of use score
  • Good points
  • Bad points
  • Mix-in chute
  • Dishwasher safe parts
  • Weight (kg)
  • Safety locking lid
  • Refrigerant used
  • Maximum ingredient volume to allow for expansion
  • Bowl material
  • Hardness selection
  • Cord storage
  • Pre freeze bowl time
  • Pre-cool setting
  • Non-slip feet
  • Automatic mode
  • End beep
  • Keep cool setting
  • Safety features
  • Noise (dB)
  • Dimensions (cm, H x W x D)
  • Mix-in alert (audible/visual)
  • Pause function
  • Maximum churning time
  • Accessories supplied
  • Manual mode
  • Shop Ethical rating
  • Bowl capacity (L)
  • Warranty (years)
  • Wattage (W)
  • Price
  • Country of origin

Results

Your filters

Clear all filters

Breville The Smart Scoop Ice Cream Machine BCI600BSS

Breville The Smart Scoop Ice Cream Machine BCI600BSS
$499
Expand to view more details.

This is the manufacturer's recommended retail price.

Compressor ice cream maker, 1 L bowl capacity.
ÐÓ°ÉÂÛ̳Expert Rating
Expand to view more details.

The ÐÓ°ÉÂÛ̳Expert Rating, our overall score, is made up of performance (60%) and ease of use (40%).


Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Performance score
Expand to view more details.
The performance score is made up of three tests – vanilla ice cream, lemon sorbet and vegan frozen yoghurt – all weighted equally.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Vanilla ice cream score
Expand to view more details.
We assess the ice cream maker's ability to churn and freeze vanilla ice cream to the correct consistency.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Lemon sorbet score
Expand to view more details.
We assess the ice cream maker's ability to process a water-based frozen dessert.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Vegan frozen yoghurt score
Expand to view more details.
We combine ingredients to assess the ice cream maker's ability to produce a vegan, non-dairy version of "ice cream" to the desired consistency.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Results for paid members only
Back to filters Go to compare selected box

Cuisinart Ice Cream and Gelato Maker ICE-100BCXA

Cuisinart Ice Cream and Gelato Maker ICE-100BCXA
$659
Expand to view more details.

This is the manufacturer's recommended retail price.

Compressor ice cream maker, 1.5 L bowl capacity.
ÐÓ°ÉÂÛ̳Expert Rating
Expand to view more details.

The ÐÓ°ÉÂÛ̳Expert Rating, our overall score, is made up of performance (60%) and ease of use (40%).


Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Performance score
Expand to view more details.
The performance score is made up of three tests – vanilla ice cream, lemon sorbet and vegan frozen yoghurt – all weighted equally.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Vanilla ice cream score
Expand to view more details.
We assess the ice cream maker's ability to churn and freeze vanilla ice cream to the correct consistency.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Lemon sorbet score
Expand to view more details.
We assess the ice cream maker's ability to process a water-based frozen dessert.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Vegan frozen yoghurt score
Expand to view more details.
We combine ingredients to assess the ice cream maker's ability to produce a vegan, non-dairy version of "ice cream" to the desired consistency.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Results for paid members only
Back to filters Go to compare selected box

Cuisinart The Cool Scoop ICE-22XA

Cuisinart The Cool Scoop ICE-22XA
$139
Expand to view more details.

This is the manufacturer's recommended retail price.

Freezer bowl ice cream maker, 1.5 L bowl capacity.
ÐÓ°ÉÂÛ̳Expert Rating
Expand to view more details.

The ÐÓ°ÉÂÛ̳Expert Rating, our overall score, is made up of performance (60%) and ease of use (40%).


Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Performance score
Expand to view more details.
The performance score is made up of three tests – vanilla ice cream, lemon sorbet and vegan frozen yoghurt – all weighted equally.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Vanilla ice cream score
Expand to view more details.
We assess the ice cream maker's ability to churn and freeze vanilla ice cream to the correct consistency.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Lemon sorbet score
Expand to view more details.
We assess the ice cream maker's ability to process a water-based frozen dessert.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Vegan frozen yoghurt score
Expand to view more details.
We combine ingredients to assess the ice cream maker's ability to produce a vegan, non-dairy version of "ice cream" to the desired consistency.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Results for paid members only
Back to filters Go to compare selected box

Davis & Waddell Essentials Electric Ice Cream Maker DES0318

Davis & Waddell Essentials Electric Ice Cream Maker DES0318
$130
Expand to view more details.

This is the manufacturer's recommended retail price.

Freezer bowl ice cream maker, 1.5 L bowl capacity.
ÐÓ°ÉÂÛ̳Expert Rating
Expand to view more details.

The ÐÓ°ÉÂÛ̳Expert Rating, our overall score, is made up of performance (60%) and ease of use (40%).


Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Performance score
Expand to view more details.
The performance score is made up of three tests – vanilla ice cream, lemon sorbet and vegan frozen yoghurt – all weighted equally.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Vanilla ice cream score
Expand to view more details.
We assess the ice cream maker's ability to churn and freeze vanilla ice cream to the correct consistency.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Lemon sorbet score
Expand to view more details.
We assess the ice cream maker's ability to process a water-based frozen dessert.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Vegan frozen yoghurt score
Expand to view more details.
We combine ingredients to assess the ice cream maker's ability to produce a vegan, non-dairy version of "ice cream" to the desired consistency.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Results for paid members only
Back to filters Go to compare selected box

KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker Attachment for Stand Mixer 5KSMICM

KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker Attachment for Stand Mixer 5KSMICM
$209
Expand to view more details.

This is the manufacturer's recommended retail price.

Freezer bowl ice cream maker, 1.9 L bowl capacity.
ÐÓ°ÉÂÛ̳Expert Rating
Expand to view more details.

The ÐÓ°ÉÂÛ̳Expert Rating, our overall score, is made up of performance (60%) and ease of use (40%).


Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Performance score
Expand to view more details.
The performance score is made up of three tests – vanilla ice cream, lemon sorbet and vegan frozen yoghurt – all weighted equally.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Vanilla ice cream score
Expand to view more details.
We assess the ice cream maker's ability to churn and freeze vanilla ice cream to the correct consistency.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Lemon sorbet score
Expand to view more details.
We assess the ice cream maker's ability to process a water-based frozen dessert.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Vegan frozen yoghurt score
Expand to view more details.
We combine ingredients to assess the ice cream maker's ability to produce a vegan, non-dairy version of "ice cream" to the desired consistency.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Results for paid members only
Back to filters Go to compare selected box

Magimix Gelato Expert

Magimix Gelato Expert
$1399
Expand to view more details.

This is the manufacturer's recommended retail price.

Compressor ice cream maker, 2 L bowl capacity.
ÐÓ°ÉÂÛ̳Expert Rating
Expand to view more details.

The ÐÓ°ÉÂÛ̳Expert Rating, our overall score, is made up of performance (60%) and ease of use (40%).


Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Performance score
Expand to view more details.
The performance score is made up of three tests – vanilla ice cream, lemon sorbet and vegan frozen yoghurt – all weighted equally.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Vanilla ice cream score
Expand to view more details.
We assess the ice cream maker's ability to churn and freeze vanilla ice cream to the correct consistency.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Lemon sorbet score
Expand to view more details.
We assess the ice cream maker's ability to process a water-based frozen dessert.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Vegan frozen yoghurt score
Expand to view more details.
We combine ingredients to assess the ice cream maker's ability to produce a vegan, non-dairy version of "ice cream" to the desired consistency.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Results for paid members only
Back to filters Go to compare selected box

Ninja Creami Ice Cream Maker NC300

Ninja Creami Ice Cream Maker NC300
$500
Expand to view more details.

This is the manufacturer's recommended retail price.

Processor ice cream maker, 0.47 L bowl capacity.
ÐÓ°ÉÂÛ̳Expert Rating
Expand to view more details.

The ÐÓ°ÉÂÛ̳Expert Rating, our overall score, is made up of performance (60%) and ease of use (40%).


Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Performance score
Expand to view more details.
The performance score is made up of three tests – vanilla ice cream, lemon sorbet and vegan frozen yoghurt – all weighted equally.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Vanilla ice cream score
Expand to view more details.
We assess the ice cream maker's ability to churn and freeze vanilla ice cream to the correct consistency.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Lemon sorbet score
Expand to view more details.
We assess the ice cream maker's ability to process a water-based frozen dessert.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Vegan frozen yoghurt score
Expand to view more details.
We combine ingredients to assess the ice cream maker's ability to produce a vegan, non-dairy version of "ice cream" to the desired consistency.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Results for paid members only
Back to filters Go to compare selected box

Ovation Ice Cream Maker OV8808

Ovation Ice Cream Maker OV8808
$299
Expand to view more details.

This is the manufacturer's recommended retail price.

Compressor ice cream maker, 1 L bowl capacity.
ÐÓ°ÉÂÛ̳Expert Rating
Expand to view more details.

The ÐÓ°ÉÂÛ̳Expert Rating, our overall score, is made up of performance (60%) and ease of use (40%).


Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Performance score
Expand to view more details.
The performance score is made up of three tests – vanilla ice cream, lemon sorbet and vegan frozen yoghurt – all weighted equally.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Vanilla ice cream score
Expand to view more details.
We assess the ice cream maker's ability to churn and freeze vanilla ice cream to the correct consistency.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Lemon sorbet score
Expand to view more details.
We assess the ice cream maker's ability to process a water-based frozen dessert.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Vegan frozen yoghurt score
Expand to view more details.
We combine ingredients to assess the ice cream maker's ability to produce a vegan, non-dairy version of "ice cream" to the desired consistency.

Unlock this by becoming a member.

Join now

Already a member? Log in now

Results for paid members only
Back to filters Go to compare selected box

Product selected for a detailed comparison

Clear all

Get full access to all our tests and reviews

or Log in